Hi, friends. We haven’t done a discussion thread in a long while so I thought today might be a good day. I’m also sending this out a little early in the hopes that’ll give more of you a chance to weigh in. We’d all benefit from whatever you have to offer.
So! This week I came across a quote attributed to Bill Wilson, the founder of Alcoholics Anonymous: “You can’t think your way to right action; you can only act your way to right thinking.”
I’ve never been to a 12-step meeting, myself, but I have a lot of respect for what AA has done to support many folks I know in practicing their integrity, so this quote really caught my eye. It’s elegantly stated. However, it describes a process orientation that is the opposite of how I generally map out my own integrity practice. First comes the discernment (lots and lots of thinking and talking), then comes the action, right?
Except, if I think about it (ha!), the reality is a large part of my integrity practice is acting first and then, especially if things don’t go the way I planned (and how often do things go exactly the way we plan?) then I think through it to figure out a better way to approach it (and understand it, meaning think about it) the next time.
I am actually acting first and thinking later a lot of the time. What?!?
What about you? Do you think first and then act? Do you act first and then, from the perspective of hindsight, figure out what you think? Does it vary depending on what the action is, how high the stakes are?
How do thinking and acting interact in your integrity practice?
Within the context of 12 step recovery, and in the Big Book, it is often cited that at the root of an alcoholic’s drinking IS their thinking.
In order to change the behavior one must not over-rationalize/over-analyze the nature of their condition ie “think” this time it will be different.
Instead one must begin to do different/act different with the aid of other people in recovery (and belief in something higher or other than oneself), and through right action, one’s thinking will begin to change.
I could be wrong (and I often am) but as I understand it, this isn’t a blanket statement for all situations, but relates to the act of drinking or not drinking.
I probably have to reflect more on this, but I know from my own personal experience that I have successfully used the “fake it till you make it” technique many times in order to shake up my perceptions of things.
While I recognise that experience and the perspective of hindsight can alter how I approach life going forward (leading to right thinking), I have created plenty of changes in my life through setting my intentions (thinking my way) towards right action.
I interpret the quote as you can't think your way to right action if you don't have your full self in on it.
If it is about something I need to spend money for I usually do a some mental debating about it first, often putting the purchase off for a few days at least if possible; Do I really need it, how much will it get used, do I already get along without it reasonably well, will it make my life a lot easier, can I build it to rather that buying it? For food items it may not be so much that way, but in some cases yes.
Asha, it's been uncanny how your themes have aligned with my life since you've started this project. We have a lot of similarities in our life stories/journeys, but it's more than that. Funny that you posed this question. I just got off the phone with my retirement accounts advisor. At the beginning of this month I fell in love with a largely wooded 5 acre lot on an island in the South Sound (Puget Sound). I didn't ponder it. I didn't even really look closely into how I was going to pay for it. I just wanted to be able to be on this land and I just felt it would work out somehow. I made an offer and it was accepted. I was like, I don't care if I have to pay penalties to take money from my IRA, just want to do this. LOL. There's a reason people don't take money out of their IRA's early. It's a lot! Still glad I just went with my gut. I have this weekend to work on some other options. I am believing more and more in the importance of intuition lately- and the importance of honing that capacity.
As a former cognitive psychologist, I freely admit that I'm biased. I vehemently disagree with the quotation. If it were true, there'd be no need for philosophy.
When it comes to making decisions, just thinking about things isn't enough. I have to actually do something to figure out what's right for me. Sure, thinking is vitally important, but it's through taking action that I truly learn and understand. By doing things, I get a better sense of the consequences and how my thoughts line up with reality. So, instead of getting stuck in my head, I attempt to embrace the power of doing and let my actions guide me towards better thinking. It's through the experience of doing that I hope to gain clarity and wisdom.
Within the context of 12 step recovery, and in the Big Book, it is often cited that at the root of an alcoholic’s drinking IS their thinking.
In order to change the behavior one must not over-rationalize/over-analyze the nature of their condition ie “think” this time it will be different.
Instead one must begin to do different/act different with the aid of other people in recovery (and belief in something higher or other than oneself), and through right action, one’s thinking will begin to change.
I could be wrong (and I often am) but as I understand it, this isn’t a blanket statement for all situations, but relates to the act of drinking or not drinking.
I probably have to reflect more on this, but I know from my own personal experience that I have successfully used the “fake it till you make it” technique many times in order to shake up my perceptions of things.
While I recognise that experience and the perspective of hindsight can alter how I approach life going forward (leading to right thinking), I have created plenty of changes in my life through setting my intentions (thinking my way) towards right action.
I interpret the quote as you can't think your way to right action if you don't have your full self in on it.
If it is about something I need to spend money for I usually do a some mental debating about it first, often putting the purchase off for a few days at least if possible; Do I really need it, how much will it get used, do I already get along without it reasonably well, will it make my life a lot easier, can I build it to rather that buying it? For food items it may not be so much that way, but in some cases yes.
Asha, it's been uncanny how your themes have aligned with my life since you've started this project. We have a lot of similarities in our life stories/journeys, but it's more than that. Funny that you posed this question. I just got off the phone with my retirement accounts advisor. At the beginning of this month I fell in love with a largely wooded 5 acre lot on an island in the South Sound (Puget Sound). I didn't ponder it. I didn't even really look closely into how I was going to pay for it. I just wanted to be able to be on this land and I just felt it would work out somehow. I made an offer and it was accepted. I was like, I don't care if I have to pay penalties to take money from my IRA, just want to do this. LOL. There's a reason people don't take money out of their IRA's early. It's a lot! Still glad I just went with my gut. I have this weekend to work on some other options. I am believing more and more in the importance of intuition lately- and the importance of honing that capacity.
As a former cognitive psychologist, I freely admit that I'm biased. I vehemently disagree with the quotation. If it were true, there'd be no need for philosophy.
When it comes to making decisions, just thinking about things isn't enough. I have to actually do something to figure out what's right for me. Sure, thinking is vitally important, but it's through taking action that I truly learn and understand. By doing things, I get a better sense of the consequences and how my thoughts line up with reality. So, instead of getting stuck in my head, I attempt to embrace the power of doing and let my actions guide me towards better thinking. It's through the experience of doing that I hope to gain clarity and wisdom.